The Ethical Cost of AI Performance

The Ethical Cost of AI Performance

Quantifying how web crawling opt-outs affect LLM capabilities

This research quantifies the Data Compliance Gap (DCG) - the performance drop when LLMs respect web crawling opt-outs from content owners.

  • Models trained on fully-compliant data show 5-15% performance degradation across tasks
  • Effects are most severe in specialized domains (e.g., biomedical research)
  • LLMs trained on opt-out-filtered datasets struggle with niche knowledge and specialized reasoning
  • Ethical compliance creates real trade-offs between model performance and respecting content owners' rights

This research highlights critical security and privacy implications as AI companies must balance regulatory compliance with competitive performance demands.

Original Paper: Can Performant LLMs Be Ethical? Quantifying the Impact of Web Crawling Opt-Outs

115 | 124